Topic: Test/Evaluation Barani and Co

[tobyportugal]

08/12/2024 PORTUGAL

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

[tobyportugal]

09/12/2024 PORTUGAL

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

[tobyportugal]

10/12/2024 PORTUGAL

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

[tobyportugal]

11/12/2024 PORTUGAL

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

[mauro63]

Very interesting comparison, it would be good to have an image of the installation to be able to evaluate how much it can influence the different behaviors, I don't think I saw it in previous messages, and, if I'm wrong, I apologize

In the absence of an image that accurately portrays the installation, I fear that all this work is an end in itself but not useful.

M.

[tobyportugal]

Very interesting comparison, it would be good to have an image of the installation to be able to evaluate how much it can influence the different behaviors, I don't think I saw it in previous messages, and, if I'm wrong, I apologize

I will post pictures when I return to Portugal, scheduled for the end of January. Where the Comet should be back in operation.
The equivalent in Belgium, of which you have had the pictures, should be operational between Christmas and New Year. Rad14/Pro3/FARS Barani (ex-Portugal updated).

In the absence of an image that accurately portrays the installation, I fear that all this work is an end in itself but not useful.

Probably.

[tobyportugal]

12/12/2024 PORTUGAL

You can see the HA rates compared to other days.

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

[tobyportugal]

13/12/2024 PORTUGAL

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]
 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

[Dvalente75]

We are waiting for the photos of the installation with great curiosity! And above all the comparisons in the next few months of the new Fars (the one with cable or without cable?) That is, does the fan only turn with solar radiation above 200 w/M2? From the reports it seems to work well but as I said I would like to have an idea of ​​the place where it is located and of course observe it for a long time!

[Dvalente75]

then even if it was Jan decided to close the purchase to private individuals and it will be necessary to turn to distributors where it will be difficult to explain to them which Fars one wants and that if it were they have available and with absurd prices! I made a request to Petra and she put them at 573€ really excessive for a screen that I consider a beta tester! There is no technical sheet nothing at all! Anyway we will see!

[Dvalente75]

So what you are doing Toby is a job that is an end in itself since NO ONE will be able to afford to buy a Fars because if Petra asked me €573 and told me that next year they will increase further at a distributor how much will I have to pay to have it €700? And then maybe after 6 months a new version comes out that is still different? I will look at your reports the only thing I will be able to do.... because honestly I will not be able to afford it and like me many other users of the forum great admirers of the "Barani" brand will have to turn to other competing products because then you know better than me the perfect screen does not exist! However I respect Jan's will to close the sale from 2025 to private individuals and no one prays to anyone! we will come to terms with it and we poor mortals will be able to afford at most a Meteoshield hoping that the distributor has the latest version because every 6 months there is a change! I hope Jan reads this post! I would be very happy! A user like many others betrayed!

[Jasper3012]

So what you are doing Toby is a job that is an end in itself since NO ONE will be able to afford to buy a Fars because if Petra asked me €573 and told me that next year they will increase further at a distributor how much will I have to pay to have it €700? And then maybe after 6 months a new version comes out that is still different? I will look at your reports the only thing I will be able to do.... because honestly I will not be able to afford it and like me many other users of the forum great admirers of the "Barani" brand will have to turn to other competing products because then you know better than me the perfect screen does not exist! However I respect Jan's will to close the sale from 2025 to private individuals and no one prays to anyone! we will come to terms with it and we poor mortals will be able to afford at most a Meteoshield hoping that the distributor has the latest version because every 6 months there is a change! I hope Jan reads this post! I would be very happy! A user like many others betrayed!

I personally wouldn’t bother to buy anything that involves electronics from Barani at the moment, until they fix the watertightness issues with their products.

[Dvalente75]

I won't have these problems because I can't afford it anymore! At most Meteoshield version ???? 1 2 3 4??? Whatever will be found! There are those like Toby and very fee users who will have the new ones and those who will have to make do!I repeat, personally, I will not spend €573 on a hybrid product! The maximum fair price would be €350 perhaps! Because if I really have to spend, I will buy an Apogee for those figures! And I am sure I have a ventilated one! However, I leave the task to those who can afford it and above all will be able to find the products from the various distributors! In Italy, for example, a distributor indicated on the Barani website no longer has any products and there would be only one left! Hoping that this one continues to sell Barani! However, if the same company has no interest in keeping the customers, I do not see why the customers should go crazy both in price and in the search for products! I will end my complaints here! I have nothing else to add except good luck to Barani for the future....

[tobyportugal]

And off we go for another ride!
1/ ALL THE ITALIANS know my installation perfectly, the only difference being that my shelters are now 1m60 off the ground in a corridor WITH NO SHADOWS.
2/ There's another post for people who want to air their grievances against Barani.
3/ If Barani has decided, for reasons of its own, to stop selling direct, please voice your grievances to whoever is entitled.
4/ Those who want a TS100, I advise them to study the final price carefully so that it is REALLY usable, not forgetting the sensor that will withstand the air flow, a real pyro, not forgetting also the cost of replacing the engine, and yes it is not exempt from breakdowns in humid environments!
5/ Yes I think I have a privilege, but this privilege also imposes providing detailed reports of TECHNICAL incidents (I'm not talking about weather).
Who here can speak, with professional experience, of reliability in electronics, mechanics and materials? Do you think that all I can say to Jan is "your thing doesn't work, I've got x less than on y? Your engine doesn't work, etc. Well no, it's much more technical and you have to be able to keep up technically!
Why did I pay for parcels from Portugal to Belgium to bring back materials? To impress? Well no, to look into the details.
Really pitiful!

[Dvalente75]

you don't have to offend me! Only that the reports you make will have no sense Because they will be only for you! In fact I have nothing against you! I am happy for you that you will continue to do your technical reports and that we will continue to just watch them! then when I can afford to buy a € 800 screen and if I find it I will also do my technical reports that have the same value as you no more no less! Best regards!

[Dvalente75]

Even if you are an expert in electronics etc. ... they have the same sense as mine and remember ... and tell me the truth for those who are not experts like you would you spend this money for the Barani Fars would you buy it for € 573? Goodbye again....

[tobyportugal]

I'm here for pleasure, not for interest, and certainly not to get bored!
As you said, I'll play and sing alone!
Post closed

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]