I serve on the board of the Belgian Meteo Club. Belgium, a small country in Europe with Brussels as its capital. Total area only 30,000 km2
Our network counts 98 Barani Meteohelix stations since its creation in 2020, more than 20 MeteoWind Iot stations and 85 MeteoRain rain gauges. In short, for Barani we were a good customer: lots of revenue and good advertising because all stations were publicly accessible (also on their allMeteo website).
After 3 years of using Barani, we can present the following figures:
- of the 98 stations, 55 have been defective: 80% of the problems are problems related to the measuring sensor, wires breaking off from the solar panel due to corrosion and the solar panel itself breaking down
- of the 20 wind stations, 6 have malfunctioned: software crashing, very fast freeze-up and cups breaking off
- of the rain gauges almost every one measures too little with some specimens up to 40% deviation.
Barani's customer service is limited to replacing the defective items, unfortunately the replacements also continue to show the same problems. In other words, solving the problem is not happening.
Most problems have started to occur after 12 to 18 months, but as the lifespan increases the problems increase even faster. So for our network a real disaster....
After reporting on the club's website that we no longer wanted to offer these devices because of what we consider to be questionable/bad quality, the manufacturer Barani closed the door completely.
Emails from us with the CEO Jan Barani simply admit that the problems are "challenging" in our Belgian climate. However, we only have a maritime climate, nothing extreme....
They also try to make us believe that we are apparently the only ones experiencing the problems mentioned above. With 98 weather stations operational (or better: were operational) we can - in our opinion - paint a representative picture of the Barani quality.
Much is promised, but unfortunately few of those promises are translated into reality.
The only product that works well is the Meteoshield. However, when electronics or software are involved, things go wrong.
Barani advertises on their website: "14 years of research, 12 years of field experience", but they forgot to add: ".... and still a failure rate exceeding 50%...". When one has 12 years of field experience and still 50% failure rate, there is something thoroughly wrong with the design and/or engineers developing these products.
For us: never again Barani, it was a real waste of money.
More info:
https://meteo-be.net/en/measuring-equipment