It is actually a very strange approach because if everyone applied that logic, then there would be no internet, there would be no search engines etc. Why? Because what you are basically suggesting is that any external link is basically bad or undesirable. I guess your "internet" would then be called "intronet" Everyone uses external links.
I agree. In fact good SEO includes links, back links, etc...
Yes, to a certain extent, but ever since Google rolled out its Penguin algorithm, the whole landscape of backlinking has changed
Me not wanting to link to competitor sites is not going to break the internet, its my preference, not the preference of billions
Me wanting to have the actual content on my site opposed to sending visitors to other sites to get it makes a lot more sense
It means more visitors, it means staying longer, it means giving the visitors the information that they need, there and then.
It also means repeat visitors, if then had to leave on a link to another site, it means i did not have what they needed, the other
site did, why would they come back to me if that other site has what they needed?
Thats the way i have always looked at it, getting the visitors, and keeping them, i used to own a large forum 38k+ members
38k because i knew what i was doing, it was called Bashys Place, i must have been doing something right