Topic: Barani MS Pro vs SmartCellino radiation shield comparison

[Jasper3012]

Jasper3012 - The Davis FARS24H is noticeably slower than the Apogee TS100. During the front even without filters, the difference can reach 0.3/0.4 deg.C. The measurement is heavily averaged. I test both, as do many colleagues in Poland. At this point I am positively surprised by the TS100, but more will be known after a few months of comparisons, when I put it together is still Barani Meteoshield Pro III.

0.3-0.4C wouldn't be much compared to the 1.7C that Kallo noticed, though.

[Jasper3012]

FYI: I have promoted the SmartCellino to be my primary radiation shield, which means it's now the top graph in the following link, with the Barani as the "Temperatuur 2". This also reverses the graph showing the difference between the shields, as it's now showing the SC temp minus the Barani temp. This means that a red/positive value is now indicative of a warmer temp on the SC and a blue/negative value indicative of a cooler temp on the Barani: https://meteo-be.net/nl/grafieken/male-brugge/last_24h

[mauro63]

FYI: I have promoted the SmartCellino to be my primary radiation shield, which means it's now the top graph in the following link, with the Barani as the "Temperatuur 2". This also reverses the graph showing the difference between the shields, as it's now showing the SC temp minus the Barani temp. This means that a red/positive value is now indicative of a warmer temp on the SC and a blue/negative value indicative of a cooler temp on the Barani: https://meteo-be.net/nl/grafieken/male-brugge/last_24h

Good morning,
you have fairly strong wind conditions, is it always like this for you?

M.

[Jasper3012]

FYI: I have promoted the SmartCellino to be my primary radiation shield, which means it's now the top graph in the following link, with the Barani as the "Temperatuur 2". This also reverses the graph showing the difference between the shields, as it's now showing the SC temp minus the Barani temp. This means that a red/positive value is now indicative of a warmer temp on the SC and a blue/negative value indicative of a cooler temp on the Barani: https://meteo-be.net/nl/grafieken/male-brugge/last_24h

Good morning,
you have fairly strong wind conditions, is it always like this for you?

M.

The wind is particularly strong today but yes, the climate is windy here, particularly in winter.

[Dvalente75]

My yesterday report

[Kallo78]

Report of yestarday

[mauro63]

Report of yesterday, interesting to evaluate classical Stevenson screen's time constant

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]


M.

[Kallo78]

Report of yestarday. Smart Cellino vs Apogee both with w31ep without filters

[Kallo78]

In pdf all the reports to 1 and 5 minutes
Both of the comparison Pro3 (with filter), Apogee, Siap
Both of the comparison Apogee, Siap

[Dvalente75]

My report yesterday

[mauro63]

Yesterday report

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

M.

[mauro63]

From last WMO Technical Conference on Meteorological and Environmental Instruments and Methods of
Observation (TECO-2024) - Vienna

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

M.

[Kallo78]

Report of yesterday. Both 1 minute and 5 minutes. Within the pdf and graphs of all systems and those only of the without filter.

[mauro63]

Yesterday report

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

M.

[Jasper3012]

I wanted to give an overview of what sensors/shields are represented on the link I’ve provided, to make it all clear:

2/6 - 14/9: Barani graph 1, Davis FARS graph 2
15/9 - 7/10: Barani graph 1, grass sensor (no shield) graph 2
8/10 - 23/11: Barani graph 1, SmartCellino graph 2
24/11 - current: SmartCellino graph 1, Barani graph 2

@tobyportugal

[mauro63]

Yesterday report

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

M.

[Kallo78]

Report of yestarday

[mauro63]

Yesterday's report, this time with 5-minute sampling

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

M.

[tobyportugal]

I wanted to give an overview of what sensors/shields are represented on the link I’ve provided, to make it all clear:

2/6 - 14/9: Barani graph 1, Davis FARS graph 2
15/9 - 7/10: Barani graph 1, grass sensor (no shield) graph 2
8/10 - 23/11: Barani graph 1, SmartCellino graph 2
24/11 - current: SmartCellino graph 1, Barani graph 2

@tobyportugal

[Kallo78]

Report of yesterday
SC very well no less than the Apogee

[mauro63]

Yesterday report

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

M.

[Jasper3012]

How November shaped up.

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

[mauro63]

Yesterday's report, not very interesting due to high ventilation

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

M.

[mauro63]

Yesterday report

 [ You are not allowed to view attachments ]

M.

[Kallo78]

Report of yesterday