Funny you should ask....
I've been mining the Google archives of the old forum in cache, and I'll be posting Gary's writeups on the previous winners soon.
Meanwhile, here's what I could find about the prior honorees:
2005 August - lighthouseweather.com
2005 Septermber - loganvillageweather
2005 October - weatherbus.com
2005 November - oldlineweather.com
2005 December - Tawas Bay
2006 January - St. James City, Fla (anole)
2006 April - Capeweather.com
2006 May - beamsville ca
I couldn't find anything before August 2005, and the cache didn't have the last in-progress poll when weatherforum.net went offline suddenly .. if someone has info before Aug 2005 or remembers what happened for Feb, Mar 2006, or what was the polling for June 2006.. please PM me with the details.
I've also captured pages with most of the final polls for the above (and the runoffs where needed).. I'll digest that and post it later.
Meanwhile.... folks should troll about and see what member sites they like, just try to nominate some that haven't been honored (lately)

Ken
Thanks,
Ken