At one point, I had 2 consoles and an Envoy. I later swapped out the Envoy for a full console. So now I have 3. One running WD, one for Cumulus. Last one is in my hallway just for viewing.
It's like you said, just setup same channels and new console will come online. But if you're not having issues, there really is no reason to get a new one. About the only thing you may want is to update the firmware of the console. But if it's version 3.0 and above, it probably doesn't even need that.
If you really wanted to update the firmware cheaper, I'd get the Belfrey Boy USB logger. It's half the cost of Davis model. Just to connect your console to a PC and update the firmware. Getting shipped from UK takes a bit longer.