I have never had a problem leaving snow and ice in my rain bucket throughout the winter. I lived in Wisconsin for two winters, when the snow took forever to melt and sat in the bucket for most of the season, and I have lived in Colorado for four winters, where the snow melts in a day when it is sunny. I have two buckets now, one with a heater and the other one that has gone through 7 winters without a cover and is still working perfectly.