So, a little more information. I don't need a replacement transmitter now. I called them back again today because it seemed I was no longer receiving info from my soil station. Long story short, we reset both the soil and ISS transmitters and everything is working. Resetting the transmitters was interesting. I'll post it here for future use.
1) Remove and disconnect the solar cover.
2) Remove the battery.
3) Just above the battery there is a little black "post" facing to the right. Insert the AC adapter from the console into this post. There is no need to plug in the AC adapter.
4) Wait two minutes.
5) The capacitor is now discharged.
6) Reconnect everything and you've "rebooted".
After step 2, I flipped DIP switch 4 on and watched the light blink. As soon as I plugged in the AC adapter the light stopped so it actually discharges almost immediately. I still waited two minutes since it was a hike to the transmitters and I didn't want to do it again.
I asked a lot of questions of the tech. This reset can fix problems where you're receiving only some data or no data. The cause can be lightning in the area not just a lightning strike. From now on, if I ever get a similar problem I'll just reset it since it's so easy.