It must be the off season. Even with the cruise ships in port, I would estimate that over 75% of the beach chairs stayed empty. <sarcasm> It is a beautiful island but not a good place for a weather enthusiast. </sarcasm> The weather doesn't change all that much and is basically the same everyday.
I would take the 75* nights and 85* sunny days over the cloudy, high in the 50s that we returned to.